Thursday, May 30, 2013

Peer Feedback



 Betül

She focused on sea animals in her lesson. Students are 3rd grade and the class is crowded and active too much. She started with a power point slide to make students familiar with sea animals and the slides were very colorful and attractive. It immediately caught their attention and also mine. It was a very effective introduction, I guess. Students were ready to start and learn. Materials that she prepared herself were well-designed and organized. That introduction part was very integrative and she engaged all students to process and by repeating animal names aloud, she did a good job. Then comes the informatioın gap activity. Students understand the instructions,because she explained them clearly and slowly, but somehow they tended to look at their partners’ paper to complete missing information. Fourtunately, Betül took the control and immediately warned them and prevent them from cheating. J To observe each and every student is a very tough thing for a teacher and I think, during the lesson, Betül was very active and managed the class very well. The activities were appropriate for their level and classrom size, but maybe the information gap activity may be a little bit difficult for them. The reason for that might be because they are not familiar with this type of activity. ( I don’t know their background so much, by the way) Last activity was to create an aquarium, as far as I can remember and that activity was more like a wrap-up and use what they learnt during the lesson. Based on my observations, they liked it because kids love to create, design things. At those ages, this type of activities could be very effective and engaging for them. Overall, I congralute Betül for doing a good job. Her lesson was effective and students learnt sea animals and made enough practice about it, so she accomplished her goals.

Elif

Elif taught first graders and the topic was toys. The class were very active and students were energetic and ready to blow up J She prepared such kind of activities that they discharged all their energy and no problems occured. She started with a game and it was very enjoyable for their age. There were toys’ pictures on the board, very colorful and attractive. She asked students to stand up and find the toy that she said and touch it. They loved it! One student came to board, she told the toy and she/he looked around, found it and touched it. The activity had movement in it, so students moved around, gave out energy and relaxed. They did not sit still, which is good.  This activity warmed them up. Then comes the matching activity. Students matched pictures with toys on the board. It was a good revision activity. Maybe, here she could have given them a worksheet,the same as the one on board, and while she was matching on the board, students could also do the same on their own worksheet. This could have been added to lesson plan. Overall, they enjoyed this activity and it served its purpose. Last activity was a very creative one. They were asked to write their favourite toys and draw a picture of it. Their thinking skills were triggerred and they were asked to write a complete sentence. I liked the last activity most and to evaluate the lesson, what I can say is they practiced toys and did different exercises, which was good to develop their skills in different aspects.

 Ümmü

She did a poetry class and she used the star diagram, which immediately catches my attention. The lesson was with 9th graders, which I am afraid of most, but she managed it very well. She built up such kind of a relationship with them that they saw her like a real teacher. She designed the activities very well and she integrated technology in her class very effectively. She knows her learners’ profile and what they are accustomed to and that’s how she shaped her lesson. By using star diagram, she made them see the overall picture and then examine the poem deeply, in detail. She showed them how to work step by step,so they understood each and every step because it was clear for them. For the star diagram, she divided the poet into subtopics (5 topics) and asked them to think and write what they can find about these topics. It is both creative and controlled activity. You give space for them to create and also by giving them the heading, you put a limit to them, which must be the case in teaching. Ümmü here is a model for a being a guide and by prompting, she shows us how to be a teacher but not by taking all control over them, instead by showing them the way that they are better to follow. For classroom management, I can see no problem. As I mentioned above, she built a good relationship with them. they respected her and did she as well.  During the whole lesson, she did not let them  lose their attention and integrate them to class discussions. Congratulations! J

       Sema

Sema started with  a gap filing activity. How enjoyable it seems! She used her voice so effectively and her gestures, as well. The activity could be done veryy boring as usual, but she made it like a game and students are very eager to give an answer when she stops and waits for it. She is standing in front of the board and readging the passage and without saying anything, when she stops,students know what is to be expected. I am amazed by such kind of synchroneity. She catches student attention by making her voice up and down. When she moves onto vocabulary practice, she told a sentence and stop it in middle and asked which word that was, students get excited and tried to guess.  She used contextualization here and it was very effective to teach and practice vocabulary. This type of tecahing strategy makes it easier for students ro remember and learn vocabulary. They do not memorise it, instead they hear words in context like in real life. Overall, it was an enyoyable and effective lesson for students, as far as I can see. They actively participate to class discussions and I do not think that they can find any moment to get bored. You can work  with learners at those ages, Sema. I’m sure that they will adore you, as you love them and love teaching.

      Ali

Ali knows how to teach and whom to teach what. He gave too much effort to pepare his lesson and I want to say thank you to him for making a great effort to be good teacher. He prepared photos to make his lesson contextualized and his activity are all bound to each other. Here, he is working with young learners, and he did everything to catch their attention and focus on the activities. At those ages,students’attention span is very short and they can easily lose their attention and focus on things around them in class. He is asking prompting questions. Ali is active during the lesson as much as his students. He is maybe much far energetic than they are. In addition to these, I want to mention the strategies that he used before he started the lesson : He showed them some shaped, I mean he drawed them on board and explained what they meant. This was a very effective technique for classroom management. You took action before the war started. Students know what to expect from the lesson and bahave accordingly. He spoke clearly but maybe a little fast. His voice was audible and this is very important for a teacher. His lesson was very visual and attention-catching. He used his own pictures and this was very authentic. Students were amazed to see their teacher projected on the board. This idea was very creative and interesting. Ali prepared his own material. As being prospective teachers, I myself always look for readymade materials, but when I watched his teaching, I was suprised and thought why not? Sometimes it is too difficult to find the appropriate material for your learners’ profile and age. Therefore, in those cases, we can take initiative and create our own materials. He was kind to students and asked them to things politely. He respected them and I’m sure that this makes students feel comfortable in class. As a conclusion, I can say that it was very well-designed and well-organized, and effective lesson plan and teaching. 

No comments:

Post a Comment